Effective Strategies for Overcoming Donor Fatigue in Online Fundraising

Woman without donor fatigue holding a credit card while using her laptop to make a donation online

Donor fatigue is one of the most notorious hurdles facing nonprofits and charities. What is donor fatigue? It’s when those who previously actively contributed seem to suddenly stop offering donations to your cause. These are also often called lapsed donors. As a result, donor fatigue directly cuts into a nonprofit’s earnings and reduces their potential to positively impact their community. There are various reasons for donor fatigue and donors to lapse. We’ll provide the best strategies for preventing and overcoming donor fatigue to keep your online fundraising consistent.

Overcoming Donor Fatigue and Lapsed Donors

There are numerous causes for donor fatigue, and they can be difficult to determine. However, there are some key things to consider in your strategies for preventing and overcoming donor fatigue in your online fundraising. Many of those strategies surround your communication and marketing. Here are a few key effective strategies:

Avoid Constant Negative Messaging

Nonprofits address some important issues and concerns in their community, and unfortunately, those come with some negative realities. Reminding donors about these issues is important for motivating them to donate, but too much can be emotionally overwhelming and tiring. Constant urgency in messaging can be similarly numbing. When everything is urgent and dire, nothing is and donors will feel defeated. In this emotional fatigue, they will stop looking at your nonprofit’s messaging, which will directly undermine any online fundraising efforts. Avoid negativity in all of your emails, social media, and other messaging surrounding your campaigns and include other kinds of updates and information.

Identify Positives and Victories 

An important alternative to negative messaging is positive ones. As part of your online fundraising strategies, incorporate messaging that identifies the positive contributions of your nonprofit. Your emails and social media posts should include stats about how many people have benefited or the statistics of certain things you have accomplished with donations. Communicate how your nonprofit is solving problems and benefiting the community. This helps donors realize the impacts of your nonprofit and their own contributions. That keeps them motivated to continue donating.

The Right Timing Is Important

The proper timing is also important in any campaign strategy. Too frequent messaging will lead to donor fatigue, but too infrequent risks donors lapsing. You want a suitable balance. However, that timing is going to depend on multiple factors. Social media messaging is typically more frequent, often multiple times a week, but less obtrusive. Emails should appear less often in users’ inboxes. You will also want to consider the season. For example, the winter holidays and Giving Tuesday are excellent general days to message fundraising efforts.

However, avoid inappropriate holidays. For example, if your nonprofit isn’t directed towards helping disadvantaged women, give space to other nonprofits on International Women’s Day. Lastly, consider your donors’ preferences. More active donors may prefer more frequent messaging and updates, while annual donors may want less frequent communications. Thankfully, email marketing platforms help track those preferences so you can custom-tailor the timing of your messaging. 

Acknowledge Donors

Along with the realization that their donations are generally accomplishing change and having an impact, direct acknowledgement is a great way to overcome and prevent donor fatigue. Be sure to have posts and newsletters that thank donors for their donations. Recognizing and celebrating individual donors is an effective way to prevent or overcome donor fatigue. Sending messages directly to donors recognizing and demonstrating how even a smaller donation directly impacted a family or community is even better for preventing lapsed donors. An easy and effective way to do this is to add personalization to an email communication by adding a value that automatically adds everyone’s first name.

Communicate About More than Fundraising

If your communication with donors is only about fundraising campaigns, this can create fatigue through the impression of a purely transactional relationship. Instead, you want to build and recognize a community of donors collaborating with your nonprofit to effect positive change. Instead, also provide updates about your nonprofit’s efforts or notify them about an event. These alternative forms of communication on all your digital channels will create a warming community that will prevent any kind of donor fatigue.

Incentivizing Donations Prevents Donor Fatigue

The good your nonprofit accomplishes is certainly an incentive unto itself, but sometimes people need a little extra push. Another avenue to help keep donors interested and energetic is to further incentivize their donations with charitable gaming. Charitable gaming, like Catch the Ace, is an effective and motivating fundraising strategy that provides donors with an extra potential incentive for their donations.

Providing Alternative Donation Methods

Individual donors might lapse or stop donating for reasons unrelated to your marketing or fundraising campaigns. They may stop donating for personal reasons, such as concerns about personal finances during an economic recession or private hardships. These aren’t truly cases of donor fatigue since other obstacles have prevented them from donating. However, these donors also typically still wish they could donate. You can accommodate them by digitally offering alternative contribution methods:

  • Donations of Time: You can accept donations of time through volunteering hours and services or inviting them to help fundraise or host/participate in events.
  • Donations of Items: Instead of money, you can accept physical donations that your nonprofit can use or give to those it benefits. Alternatively, you can also accept donations of physical items by organizing a thrift sale, where all proceeds will go to your nonprofit.
  • Donations of Awareness: Even if community members can’t donate money or things, they can spread knowledge and awareness of your nonprofit and its fundraising efforts. They can forward emails or share social posts about ongoing campaigns to their friends and followers, helping to grow your reach and donor pool.

Beat Fatigue, Keep Donors Energized

With these effective strategies, you’ll be able to overcome and prevent donor fatigue. Lapsed donors rarely have lost interest in the cause and work your nonprofit accomplishes. Demonstrating your achievements, acknowledging their contributions, providing incentives, or offering alternatives are key strategies for fighting that pernicious donation fatigue. If you want to discuss how to improve your messaging or want to develop your fundraising strategies to retain donors and prevent fatigue, contact Rosewood Fundraising.

Share the Post:


More Posts

Digital fundraising solutions for Canadian non-profits

Our team works with nonprofit organizations of all shapes and sizes to amplify your mission and drive digital marketing toward fundraising success.